In the quaint town of Sugarcreek, Ohio, policewoman Rachel Troyler (Sarah Lancaster) is fiercely protective of her three Amish aunts. When a penniless stranger named Joe (Tom Everett Scott) shows up with his five-year-old son, the aunts insist on helping them. But Rachel has immediate suspicions and devotes herself to investigating Joe’s secretive past, even as she finds herself falling for him.