Chris Conci
Absolutely pathetic attempt to remake a classic. Ruins the story in favor of liberal pandering. The blackwashing would be fine if it didn't read like some bad southern caricature. I honestly couldn't get through more than half the movie without falling asleep. If race politics gives you a hard on then maybe this is the film for you, but if your after a good remake of a Roald Dahl classic. Your going to be more than sorely disappointed and confused.
16 people found this review helpful
Dave Bath
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
Huston in the old version is impossible to beat, but this new version has merit, does not attempt a mere clone, has a more satisfying backstory and denouement and a much more interesting conclusion/coda than the original. That huge difference in the coda between the old and new films may generate the hate. The more conventional, saccharin, Hollywood "happy ending" of the old version may be preferred by some, but the new ending has a different, stranger, magic some kids would prefer.
1iving deadgr1
Octavia Spencer saved this movie, however I wish I could say the same for Anne Hathaway the accent, performance and character design was just a tad cringe. I am a huge fan of the book and original screen play, though I did appreciate the playfulness of this adaptation it just fell flat in the storytelling of a creepy fairy tale. CGI should never be used as a short cut to great story telling.