True Crime Story: It Couldn't Happen Here

A stranger is convicted of a local girl's murder, but a new sheriff calls everything into question.

A small college town questions the role law enforcement may have played in a student's death.

An out-of-town lawyer argues the innocence of a man put on death row for a brutal crime.

The murder of a gender-nonconforming teen remains unsolved despite pressure from the community.

Law enforcement closes a cold case, but new questions about the investigation have been raised.

A fight between two lobstermen leaves locals disputing whether a death was self-defense or murder.