Based on the best selling novel by Hallie Ephron. Ivy and David Rose, happily married high school sweethearts, are having a yard sale to try and clear out their home before the upcoming birth of their first child. Among the bargain hunters is Melinda White, a high school classmate who's also pregnant. When Melinda disappears and no one can remember seeing her leave the sale, the Roses shockingly become the prime suspects and all the evidence suggests that David may have murdered her. Anastasia Griffith, Brendan Fehr, Clea Duvall star in this Lifetime Movie Network Original film.