Anthony Wilczewski
This is definitely something new and different that IMO was ahead of its time. It's not perfect, and there are some things about it that could've been done or explained better. But these flaws can be overlooked by the good things this story offers. I will say that not everyone might be a fan, especially if they're die hard traditional fans. But if you're willing to invest in a grounded story set in a darker more familiar world where many viewpoints will clash together, I recommend this.
Aidan Daugherty
I don't understand most of the hate for this movie. Its cinematography is absolutely stunning, the colors, and framework are astonishing. The way Zach Snyder does these things makes his movies often times look like comic book frames, almost as if you could take screenshots of the screen, and give characters speech bubbles. The slo-mo that happens alot in his movies is a little goofy, but it really drives home that comic book feel. He is quite a unique and visionary director and I enjoy his work.
Ryan Gill
The theatrical version was not great, but this extended edition is outstanding. I wish WB hadn't gutted the film of character moments and a subplot about Louis investigating the bullet and Luthor, along with Clark's entire motivation for wanting to take down The Batman. This film is outstanding. 5 stars.